Don’t overlook these foods.

Grilled Butterflied Turkey Rosemary Garlic Gravy

Thomas J. Story

On Thanksgiving Day, the emphasis is always on the turkey. We spend days thawing it out (if it’s frozen) and brining it. And then when it’s time to cook, it roasts for hours under a watchful eye. It’s the star of the show, and for good reason, it is the main protein after all.

Because we spend so much time on the turkey, other dishes can become an afterthought, and that may mean those other dishes might not end up tasting as good as the turkey.

To avoid that from happening, we asked professional chefs what they thought were the most overlooked, underrated Thanksgiving foods. The dishes that people often forget about, but they shouldn’t because when made with more effort and love, they’ll take your meal to the next level. Take a look at their thoughts below.

Try Roasted Turkey Gravy this Thanksgiving.

Thomas J. Story

Gravy

Sauces, in general, are the thing that people phone in, but a great sauce can make or break a dish, says Dustin Valette, Chef-Vintner, Proprietor of Valette, The Matheson, and Valette Wines in Healdsburg, California.

And gravy is the most important sauce of them all on Thanksgiving (some would say tied with cranberry). “Everyone focuses on getting the turkey perfectly cooked, the potatoes creamy and the stuffing just right, but gravy is the thing that brings everything together,” says Timothy Ralphs, Executive Chef at The Scottsdale Resort & Spa. “It adds moisture, richness and flavor to the entire plate – the best sides are made better with a good gravy. It might not always get the spotlight, but Thanksgiving dinner wouldn’t be the same without it.”

Green Beans with Chanterelles and Cipollini are far from boring.

Erin Kunkel

Vegetables

“Everyone focuses on the turkey, stuffing and potatoes, but well-prepared seasonal vegetables can be some of the best food on the table,” says Eric Klein, Senior Vice President of Culinary at Wolfgang Puck Catering in Los Angeles. “Roast them properly, give them good seasoning, some fresh herbs and a little acidity, and people go back for seconds.”

In particular, greens beans are an afterthought. “People don’t take time to cook good green beans, al dente, seasoned right; it’s a perfect crisp dish,” says Jamie Olivares, Executive Chef of Omni San Diego Hotel at The Ballpark.

Don’t forget about carrots and squash, adds Gus Trejo, Executive Chef at Bernardus Lodge & Spa in Carmel Valley, California. “A carrot or squash grown well and picked in season can be as exciting as anything on the table. I roast carrots whole until they caramelize, then blend the tops into a pesto with garlic, olive oil and toasted nuts to spoon over them. You use the whole plant, nothing goes to waste, and it tastes like the farm it came from.”

Infuse the flavors of chai into the classic holiday relish with this Spiced-Tea Cranberry Sauce.

Iain Bagwell

Cranberry Sauce

While chefs have differing opinions on canned versus homemade, many agreed that cranberry sauce or relish is an afterthought. 

“Homemade cranberry sauce is one of the most underrated items on the Thanksgiving table,” says Executive Chef Chris Knouse of Castle Hot Springs. “Thanksgiving meals tend to be rich, heavy, and indulgent, with dishes like turkey, stuffing, gravy, and casseroles all competing for space on the plate. A good cranberry sauce brings brightness, tartness, and acidity that helps cut through that richness and balance the meal. I like making it with fresh cranberries and orange juice because the citrus adds another layer of acidity and freshness. It may not get the same attention as the main dishes, but it’s often the element that makes every bite taste a little better.”

Quentin Garcia, Executive Chef of Lola Rose Grande Mezze at the Thompson Palm Springs prefers cranberry jelly from a can. “Yes, I’m serious,” he says. “For years I ignored it. Then I converted. I want the wobbling, can-shaped version that slides out intact and somehow survives every family gathering. The sweetness and acidity cut through rich turkey and gravy so perfectly it’s almost annoying how well it works.”

Make this Buttermilk Cornbread Stuffing and it might just be the star of your dinner table.

Thomas J. Story

Stuffing

“Stuffing is sometimes treated as an afterthought, yet it can be one of the most flavorful dishes on the table,” says Massimo Falsini, Chef and Partner of Caruso’s in Montecito, California. “I make a mushroom duxelles by cooking finely chopped mushrooms until their moisture evaporates and their flavor becomes concentrated, then fold it into the stuffing with freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano. The mushrooms contribute earthy depth and the cheese adds savory complexity. It is a small adjustment that makes a familiar dish memorable while respecting its American roots.”

Savor this elegant and herbaceous take on everyone’s favorite appetizer: Keith Corbin’s Deviled Eggs.

Thomas J. Story

Appetizers

“I think the most overlooked Thanksgiving food is a great appetizer.  We love to make deviled eggs as you can make it the day before and keep it in the fridge,” says David Nayfeld, Chef and Co-owner of Che Fico and other restaurants in the San Francisco Bay area

Holly Jiyin, Chef, Research and Development of José Andrés Group and Zaytinya in Culver City, California, agrees on the deviled eggs front: “Another Southern classic. Maybe since I’m a chef and don’t like to waste, I will eat anything in sight that’s been overlooked!” 

Candied Yam Gratin with Brown Butter and Pecans is a real crowd-pleaser.

Thomas J. Story

Candied Yams

“I’m going to defend candied yams for a minute,” says Jarell Tucker, Director of Culinary at The Wigwam in Litchfield Park, Arizona. “There’s a difference between properly candied yams and sweet potatoes swimming in syrup. I want the potatoes tender, holding their shape, with butter, warm spices, and a glaze that’s reduced enough to coat them. You should still be able to taste the sweet potato.”

The dough for these Buttery Dinner Rolls is actually super easy to work with.

Annabelle Breakey

Dinner Rolls

“The most underrated Thanksgiving food is the classic dinner roll,” says Pascal Maalouli, Executive Sous Chef at Royal Palms Resort and Spa in Scottsdale, Arizona. “I personally love using a roll to scoop up a little bit of everything on my plate and enjoying it all in one bite.”