It’s not the end of the world if you run out of something.

Turkey and all the fixins can be made ahead and enjoyed in the outdoors with tips from Adventure Chef Adam Glick

Thomas J. Story

Turkey and all the fixins can be made ahead and enjoyed in the outdoors with tips from Adventure Chef Adam Glick

It’s a common Thanksgiving mishap: you’re happily in a cooking groove, everything seems to be going well, and then… you realize you have completely run out of (insert crucial ingredient here). Don’t panic—that doesn’t mean the meal is completely ruined. It’s just calls for a clever substitution.

But how can you make a swap that won’t leave your dish tasting completely off? We asked professional chefs for their best substitution hacks for some of the most common Thanksgiving ingredients, and with some pantry staples and ingenuity, the dishes won’t know what they’re missing.

The first thing to do when you run out of something? Don’t get too precious about the swap and use some common cooking sense.

“My main professional advice is not to become obsessed with replacing an ingredient with an exact equivalent, but rather to understand the role it plays in the recipe,” says Claudio Hotter, executive chef at Marquis Loa Cabos Resort & Spa. “If it provides acidity, look for another source of acidity; if it adds moisture, find a substitute that preserves that texture. Cooking is all about balance. During Thanksgiving, when several dishes are being prepared at once, flexibility and adaptability are just as important as following a recipe to the letter. With good ingredients, proper technique, confidence in the process, and a little heart, it is possible to handle any unexpected situation without compromising the quality of the experience.”

The second thing to do? Take a look at these common ingredients and their substitutions below.

Thomas J. Story

Stock

“If you run short on stock, water with a splash of soy sauce and a little tomato paste can add depth in a pinch,” says Roy Yamaguchi, Executive Chef of Ocean House at OUTRIGGER Kaua’i Beach Resort & Spa.

Jarell Tucker, Director of Culinary at The Wigwam in Litchfield Park, Arizona, suggests using vegetable trimmings as another workaround.

“If I run short on stock, I’m not automatically reaching for water,” he says. “I’ll take the vegetable trimmings from preparing dinner, add some onion, garlic, and herbs, and make a quick broth. It’s not going to have the same depth as a stock that’s been cooking for hours, but it gives you something to work with. Just be selective about your trimmings. Not everything belongs in a stockpot.”

Fresh Herbs

“Out of fresh herbs? Use about one-third as much dried herb and add it earlier in the cooking process,” says Yamaguchi.

Buttermilk

“If you run out of buttermilk, add a little lemon juice or vinegar to regular milk,” says Eric Klein, Senior Vice President of Culinary at Wolfgang Puck Catering in Los Angeles.

Yogurt and milk can also work if you’re using the buttermilk for biscuits or a quick bread, according to Executive Chef Martín Munguía at Rancho Valencia Resort & Spa in San Diego, California. 

“Whisk together three-quarters of a cup of plain yogurt and one-quarter cup of milk. It gives you a similar tang and consistency,” he says.

boris sv/Getty Images

Butter

“Olive oil goes further than butter,” says Emily Brubaker, Executive Chef at Omni La Costa Resort & Spa in Carlsbad, California. “If you finish all your baking and run out of my favorite thing (butter!), you can adjust recipes with oil. For example, if you don’t have butter for your mashed potatoes, a beautifully flavored Spanish olive oil, used sparingly, will seriously amplify the flavor and give you that rich mouthfeel.”

Full-fat Greek yogurt can also be a good butter substitute for muffins, quick breads, cakes, or pancakes, adds Eric Sandmen, Executive Director, Cuilinary Operations at Alisal Ranch in Solvang, California.

Eggs

“If I run out of eggs when breading, I’ll use mayo as a binder. It’s made with oil and egg, so it helps the breading stick, and it’s an easy substitute that works on the fly,” says Cesar Ruiz, Chef de Cuisine at Omni Tempe Hotel at ASU.

“If you run out of large eggs while making a quick bread, such as pumpkin or banana nut bread, applesauce is a great substitute,” says Roy Hendrickson, Executive Chef at San Diego Mission Bay Resort.

Salt

You might not run out of salt, but if you are looking for a flavor substitute, try miso and soy. “They can be very salty on their own, but when incorporated into recipes in acts as a salt substitute and adds ‘umami,’” says Kyle St. John, Executive Chef of The Ranch at Laguna Beach.

Executive Chef, Mugen at ESPACIO The Jewel of Waikiki, Colin Sato, also recommends swapping in fish sauce or Maggi seasoning.

Iain Bagwell

Heavy Cream

“One of my favorite tricks is using plain Greek yogurt or sour cream in place of heavy cream when it makes sense,” says Michael Galatioto, Executive Sous Chef at Hilton Sedona Resort at Bell Rock. “You get that richness and a little tang without completely changing the dish. I love adding a little Greek yogurt to pumpkin pie filling or sour cream to mashed potatoes.”

Baking Powder

“For baking, if I run out of baking powder, I use a combination of baking soda and cream of tartar as a quick substitute. It’s an easy swap that saves an extra trip to the grocery store, especially during the busy holiday season,” says Ingrid Shelton, Executive Chef at Carté Hotel in San Diego, California.

Aquafaba

“If you don’t know, aquafaba is the liquid that comes from canned garbanzo (chickpeas) beans,” says Dominique St. Pierre, Senior Sous Chef at Sheraton Phoenix Downtown. “This is a perfect replacement if you are replacing one or two eggs. You can use it to replace more but your cake will come out dense and crumbly. If you whip the aquafaba first it will add lightness to your cake.”