Professional Chefs Share Their Biggest Thanksgiving Pet Peeves
Plus, what they’d do instead.
Vicki Jauron, Babylon and Beyond Photography/Getty Images
People have a lot of opinions about Thanksgiving. We have canned cranberry enthusiasts and homemade cranberry sauce purists. There are people who love the marshmallow topping on sweet potatoes and some who say it ruins the whole dish. And some people just hate turkey.
It’s no surprise that professional chefs have strong opinions about Thanksgiving. When cooking the meal and the dinner itself is the biggest part of the holiday, it makes sense that they’d have something to say. We were curious to see what their Thanksgiving pet peeves were, so we asked them, and they didn’t hold back.
It’s important to keep in mind that they aren’t trying to yuck someone’s yum, so to speak. They just want to help home cooks succeed on a high stress day.
“Everyone seems to have a strong opinion on the ‘right’ way to cook a Thanksgiving turkey,” says Roy Hendrickson, Executive Chef at San Diego Mission Bay Resort. “As a chef, I think it’s important to remember that there’s no single approach that works for everyone, and the best method often comes down to personal preference and technique.”
Use the above advice for the turkey and beyond this holiday. See their pet peeves below—and what they’d do instead.

Thomas Barwick/Getty Images
Pet Peeve: Dry Turkey
“There’s nothing worse than spending all that time preparing a Thanksgiving meal only to serve a turkey that’s dry and lacking flavor,” says Brooke Tadena, Executive Chef at Prince Waikiki.
The Solution: “I always recommend wet brining your turkey before roasting. It helps lock in moisture and keeps the meat juicy, tender and flavorful,” he says.
Pet Peeve: Vegetables as an Afterthought
“My biggest pet peeve is when the vegetables become an afterthought,” says Andrew Juinio, Executive Chef at Carmel Valley Ranch. “People spend days planning the turkey and dessert, then throw together vegetables at the very last minute. The sides are what create balance and bring freshness to the meal. Another pet peeve is overcomplicating recipes and masking great ingredients with too many competing flavors. If you have beautiful produce from a local farm or garden, let it shine.”
The Solution: “Start with the best products you can find and keep the preparation simple,” he says. “A perfectly roasted butternut squash from Swank Farms with a touch of brown butter and house salt can be more memorable than a complicated casserole. Focus on quality ingredients and proper execution instead of adding more components.”
Pet Peeve: Everything Soft, Sweet, and Rich
“My biggest pet peeve is a plate where everything is soft, sweet, and rich,” says Martín Munguía, Executive Chef of Rancho Valencia Resort & Spa in San Diego, California. “Sweet potatoes don’t always need marshmallows, carrots don’t always need a glaze, and every vegetable doesn’t need cream.”
The Solution: “Roasted carrots with cumin, yogurt, and lemon. Or something crisp and acidic,” he says.
Pet Peeve: Poor Timing
“Poor timing and an early Thanksgiving dinner,” says Joseph L. Paire III, Executive Chef of Claremont Resort & Club in Berkeley, California. “Every dish takes time to prepare, so planning ahead is essential to getting everything on the table at the right time. Thanksgiving dinner should be served at supper time not so early that it feels like lunch!”
The Solution: “Plan ahead by mapping out cooking times for each dish and creating a schedule to ensure everything is ready to serve together at the ideal dinner time,” he says.

GMVozd/Getty Images
Pet Peeve: Food Not Served at the Right Temperature
“My most annoying pet peeves are hot food not served hot, and cold food not served cold,” says Niklesh Modi, Director of Food and Beverage at Harrah’s Resort Southern California in Funner, California. “Take the time to prepare your dinner by having the correct serving vessels.”
The Solution: “I would say utilize your toaster ovens, crock pots, etc. to maintain good temps on the hot items, and freeze your bowls before filling to emphasis the cold on the cold items.
Pet Peeve: Pumpkin Spice Everything
“This might not be a popular opinion, but my biggest Thanksgiving pet peeve is pumpkin spice everything—outside of a really good pumpkin pie or pumpkin crunch, of course!” says Shaymus Alwin, Executive Chef of Rosewood Kona Village. “Growing up in New England, I was surrounded by pumpkin spice season from the end of August through the holidays. After months of seeing it, smelling it, and tasting it in just about everything, I reached my limit. No offense to the pumpkin spice lovers out there, but I think we can give the blend a little break!”
The Solution: “I’d encourage people to explore other warm spices, like Chinese five-spice, cardamom, and mace, rather than relying on the same pumpkin spice blend in everything,” he says. “You can also work with individual spices to bring out different flavors, or lean into fresh herbs for a more savory, aromatic approach. Thanksgiving is a great opportunity to experiment with seasonal ingredients and unexpected flavor combinations without making every dish taste like pumpkin spice.”
Pet Peeve: Oversized Menus
“My biggest pet peeve is when the cook becomes so consumed by an oversized menu that they miss the celebration,” says Massimo Falsini, Chef and Partner of Caruso’s in Montecito, California. “Thanksgiving, to me, is about being with family.”
The Solution: “Choose a manageable number of dishes and prepare as much as possible ahead of time,” he says. “I would rather serve a few thoughtfully executed dishes and enjoy the people at my table than spend the entire holiday rushing between the oven and the stove.”
Pet Peeve: Everything Beige
“A table where everything is beige: When every dish is butter, cream and starch, the table looks flat and the meal gets heavy by the third bite,” says Gus Trejo, Executive Chef at Bernardus Lodge & Spa in Carmel Valley, California.
The Solution: “Build in contrast so the table frames the meal: crisp fresh radishes and a quick pickle of red onions for color, crunch and acidity,” he says. “Your turkey should be golden brown, but toss a fresh chiffonade of parsley with finely zested citrus rind and rub it over the bird just before serving. It transforms both the look and the taste—and suddenly, you have a spread that reflects the colors of the season, and feels as good as it tastes.”

Maren Caruso/Getty Images
Pet Peeve: A Dirty Kitchen
“Looking back after a big meal and seeing a kitchen turned upside down with dirty dishes and dirty countertops can certainly turn a pleasurable evening into a nightmare,” says Joaquin Estolano, Executive Chef at Grand Hyatt Indian Wells. “No one needs to work too hard after a meal that can arguably put you to rest!”
The Solution: “Clean as you go!” He says. “Encourage a select few to pitch in while enjoying good conversation with a drink on hand. The kitchen can be the attraction of a good environment and with the right coordination and energy, all that would be left to clean after the meal is over is what’s in front of you and your guests. From there you stuff it into the dishwasher, press play and walk away, done!”
Pet Peeve: Taking Shortcuts with Stuffing
“It deserves just as much attention as the turkey, and the difference is obvious when it’s made the right way,” says Ben Martinek, Executive Culinary Director of Pendry Newport Beach.
The Solution: “Do as much prep as possible ahead of time,” he says. “Toast the bread, prep the vegetables, make the stock, and brine the turkey a day or two in advance. Thanksgiving is a lot less stressful when you’re not trying to do everything at once.”
Pet Peeve: Hard Butter
“My biggest Thanksgiving pet peeve is not having soft butter on the table,” says Nicholas Escobar, Executive Chef at Marriott Irvine Spectrum. “Too many times, caught in the whirlwind, all the food is beautifully prepared and ready to eat and the butter gets put out last. I end up fighting to cut my piece and smear on my dinner roll.
The Solution: “I tend to now leave my butter out to temper and then whip it in my Kitchen Aid for an easier spreadable version,” he says.
Pet Peeve: Marshmallows on Sweet Potatoes
“My biggest pet peeve is marshmallows on sweet potatoes,” says Brandon Sloan, Executive Chef of Pendry San Diego. “Yams are naturally sweet and by adding processed marshmallows on top you are losing the best part of what makes the sweet potato great!”
The Solution: “Instead just do some softened butter mixed with a bit of salt, brown sugar, and rosemary and that is all you need,” he says.