The Surprising Essential Ingredients You Need for Thanksgiving, According to Professional Chefs
Add these to your grocery shopping list.
Iain Bagwell
The biggest part of Thanksgiving hosting prep (aside from planning the menu and taking into account everyone’s allergies and preferences) is the grocery shopping. You make the list(s), check it twice (or many times), head to the store (or multiple), and hope you got absolutely everything you need and won’t have to make any last-minute trips to the grocery store.
There are some ingredients that you’ll want to keep in bulk for the marathon cooking session. You know, the essentials that go in just about every recipe.
“The basics I always recommend are quality unsalted butter, eggs, all-purpose flour, granulated and brown sugar, kosher salt, fresh black pepper, ground cinnamon, whole nutmeg, and vanilla extract, says Executive Chef Chris Knouse of Castle Hot Springs. “Those ingredients form the foundation of countless holiday dishes, from cookies and pies to gravies and roasted vegetables. I also like to keep plenty of onions, garlic, citrus, and chicken stock on hand because they add depth and flavor.”
Aside from the essentials, chefs recommend keeping a few other surprising ingredients on hand to really punch up your dishes this Turkey Day. These are the basics you didn’t know you needed (there are even some non-food items here, too)—take the chef recommendations below.

Thomas J. Story
Vinegar
“An overlooked staple is good-quality vinegar,” says Knouse. “A splash of sherry, apple cider, or red wine vinegar can wake up a dish that tastes flat and help balance the rich flavors that dominate holiday menus. I almost always finish a winter squash soup with some sherry or apple cider vinegar(and a little honey).”
Jarell Tucker, Director of Culinary at The Wigwam in Litchfield Park, Arizona, stresses the importance of sherry. “People often reach for more salt or butter when something doesn’t taste quite right,” he says. “Sometimes the dish doesn’t need either. A little acidity can bring everything into focus, particularly with rich sauces and roasted vegetables. The trick is knowing when to stop.”
Citrus
“Fresh citrus is one people sometimes overlook,” explains Eric Klein, Senior Vice President of Culinary at Wolfgang Puck Catering in Los Angeles. “Lemon can brighten gravy, vegetables and rich side dishes without making them taste lemony. I also like to have Dijon mustard and good vinegar nearby. A small amount of acidity can wake up a dish that feels too rich or flat.”
Cornstarch
“A simple slurry can save a broken gravy or help make a shiny glace for your mashed potatoes,” advises Joaquin Estolano, Executive Chef at Grand Hyatt Indian Wells.
Disposables
Aside from ingredients, make sure you have essentials like foil, plastic wrap, and parchment paper.
“Parchment paper is one of those things that’s easy to overlook until you need it,” explains Joseph Kudrak, Executive Chef at Green Valley Ranch Resort & Casino in Henderson, Nevada. “I always recommend keeping a roll on hand during the holidays, especially if you’re baking lots of cookies or making multiple batches of treats. It helps prevent sticking, makes cleanup much easier, and means you can move between recipes with less fuss.”

heinstirred/Getty Images
Red Wine
“Always keep a good bottle of red wine on hand for making sauces and braising slow-cooked meats,” says Pascal Maalouli, Executive Sous Chef at Royal Palms Resort and Spa in Phoenix, Arizona. “Red wine is richer and fuller-bodied than white wine, making it a perfect addition to dishes during the holiday season. Swapping a cornstarch slurry for a roux, or vice versa, is also a great way to thicken holiday pan drippings to achieve the perfect gravy consistency.”
White Miso
“White miso is one of my favorites. A little bit mixed into butter adds incredible depth to roasted vegetables or even mashed potatoes,” says Juan Carlos Cabezas, Executive Chef of Charlotte Restaurant & Lounge at Lotte Hotel Seattle.
Dried Mushrooms
“Taos is known for it wild mushrooms I always keep dried porcini at home,” says Executive Chef Noah Pettus of juliette at Hotel Willa in Taos, New Mexico. “A handful rehydrated adds deep savory flavor to gravy, stuffing, or soup, and the soaking liquid is basically free stock.”

Courtesy of Williams Sonoma
Baking Trays
“You always think you have enough until you’ve got vegetables roasting, desserts baking, and sides warming all at once. No one wants a tray shortage in the middle of Thanksgiving,” says Quentin Garcia, Executive Chef of Lola Rose Grande Mezzo at the Thompson Palm Springs.
Acid
Along with vinegar and citrus, think about using tomato paste or fish sauce, recommends Chef Alexis Brown of Henrietta in Los Angeles.
“Food around the holidays tends to be so heavy; at least the food that I was used to eating growing up,” she says. “It was dairy and gluten galore, and I always wanted something to cut through all of those flavors. Acid! Maybe that’s sour cream or yogurt in mashed potatoes instead of cream. Adding lemon juice to those green beans and stuffing. Maybe some rice vinegar for those mushrooms. Keep that in mind this holiday season.”
Cream of Tartar and Evaporated Milk
“Cream of tartar and evaporated milk are two easy-to-overlook ingredients that come in handy for holiday baking and cooking,” says Joseph L. Paire III, Executive Chef of Claremont Resort & Club in Berkeley, California.
Potato Starch
“One of my favorite versatile ingredients is potato starch,” says Roy Yamaguchi, Executive Chef of Ocean House at OUTRIGGER Kaua’i Beach Resort & Spa. “It’s great for thickening sauces and can also be used in baking and deep-frying batters. Plus, it’s naturally gluten-free, making it a useful alternative for a variety of holiday recipes.”

Thomas J. Story
Fresh Chervil
“One ingredient I think people overlook is fresh chervil,” says Andrew Juinio, Executive Chef at Carmel Valley Ranch. “It’s delicate with notes of parsley and anise, and it can brighten rich holiday dishes in a way that’s unexpected.”
Nutmeg and Cardamom
“Two of my favorite seasonings to keep around this time of year are nutmeg and cardamom,” says Dominique St. Pierre, Senior Sous Chef at Sheraton Phoenix Downtown. “I don’t think cardamom is used enough in holiday cooking, it brings a bright, zest lemon pop with gentle hints of fresh flowers and when combined with nutmeg and cinnamon you’re creating a warm, intensely aromatic, multi-layered flavor profile.”
Maple Syrup
“Maple syrup is one of the ingredients I always stock heavily,” says Marcus Stewart, Executive Chef at Shore Lodge in McCall, Idaho. “It’s endlessly versatile for the holidays: glazes for roasted vegetables or ham, in dressings, for sweetening cocktails, or even as a quick swap when you run low on honey or brown sugar. A good bottle of pure maple syrup (dark amber or robust) is something I never want to run out of.”
Finishing Salt
“Another often-overlooked item is flaky finishing salt. A small sprinkle right before serving can make dishes taste more vibrant and restaurant-quality,” says David Schaumburger, Executive Chef of The Ritz-Carlton Denver.

Courtesy of Amazon
Thermometer
Don’t forget the handy kitchen gadgets.
“I always recommend having a good thermometer, preferably one that has a probe with a wire so you can track the temperature of the turkey while it cooks,” says Patrick Munster, Executive Chef at Don’s Prime at Fountainebleau Las Vegas. “You never want to overcook your breast. I like the TempPro TempSync 650-foot Bluetooth Meat Thermometer.”
Twine
David Nayfeld, Chef and Co-owner of Che Fico and other restaurants in the San Francisco area, says you should always have twine in your kitchen.
We only recommend things we love. If you buy something through our site, we might earn a commission.